Tompkins Table will survive despite class list changes, creator says
Peter Tompkins, who has compiled the annual ranking of Colleges since 1981, said he does not expect a “deluge of students” to opt-out from the lists
Cambridge’s unofficial college league table will continue to be valid even though students may soon have a simple option to opt out of sharing their exam results, its creator has said.
On Tuesday, Varsity reported that the University Council had approved proposals which would offer students a simplified opt-out from class lists of exam results. The change potentially threatens the future of the Tompkins Table, which ranks colleges by their tripos results, and is reliant upon enough exam results being made public to ensure its findings are valid.
Peter Tompkins, who has compiled the Tompkins Table since 1981, said he “would not personally expect a deluge of students to wish to absent their names from the results list”.
The Tompkins Table, which Trinity College has topped for the past seven years, is compiled independently of the University. It has been published in Varsity for the past two years, having previously appeared in The Independent. The University also produces its own ranking, called the Baxter Table, which the colleges and faculties use internally to assess performance.
In its initial proposal, revealed in April 2016, which called for abolition of the class lists, the University said the Tompkins Table “would cease to be published” if publication ceased. In the consultation which led to that recommendation, it was noted that several colleges “would not object to [the Tompkins table] disappearing”.
That aligned with the wishes of several campaigners, who said that the rankings perpetuated a negative competitive atmosphere between colleges. They included former CUSU president Priscilla Mensah, who welcomed the initial proposal for abolition as an opportunity to “eradicate the negative culture created by league tables (and public class lists) in Cambridge”. In Michaelmas 2015, CUSU adopted policy opposing both class lists and the Tompkins Table.
CUSU’s anti-class lists policy was dramatically overturned in a student referendum last November, but its anti-Tompkins Table policy still technically stands. With class lists set to continue, however, there is no practical way to stop Tompkins producing a ranking except large-scale opt-outs.
They are a possibility: in the referendum last year, 2,106 students voted to abolish the lists. If a significant proportion of those decided to opt-out, the validity of the ranking could be questioned. Under the current system, where students have to go through a lengthy approvals process to have their names taken off the printed lists, opt-out figures have never been high enough: in 2016, 39 names were omitted from the Senate House lists; this rose to 86 names in 2017.
There is also the possibility that a concentrated boycott within a single college could invalidate its results within the Tompkins Table, and damage the overall usefulness of the ranking. Tompkins said he did not “expect any college to particularly encourage their members to remove their names”, but the possibility does make the rankings vulnerable to concentrated student action.
Professor Graham Virgo, the pro-vice-chancellor for education, said the new opt-out system, if it is approved by Regent House, “will be available for the main examination period” – meaning Tompkins’ confidence could be put to the test in the coming months.
● Separately, the proposed changes to class list publication were welcomed yesterday by Save The Class List, the student group which led the campaign to overturn CUSU’s policy against the lists. “We are delighted that the class lists are being retained with an easy opt out. This is the result we campaigned for,” its founders said.
- Lifestyle / How to survive a visit from a home friend19 November 2024
- Comment / Cambridge’s LinkedIn culture has changed the meaning of connection15 November 2024
- Comment / Give humanities students a pathway to academia15 November 2024
- Comment / Cambridge hasn’t been infantilised, it’s grown up15 November 2024
- Features / Vintage Varsity: the gowns they are a-going15 November 2024